When speaking to the Bermuda Sun, Mr. Dunkley said he
thought it useless for the PLP to have set aside $50,000 as a reserve measure to fund the
re-birth of overseas recruitment and if manpower is low and there's a shortage of
Bermudians coming forward then, in the short term, to bolster numbers, Bermuda should
recruit from overseas.
Monday's double armed robbery is according to Commissioner
Wayne Perinchief, indicative of a society which sees cracks in its Police Service.
Wake up guys. Your drug problem is indicative of the
utter contempt shown of the police service by those who import and distribute.
Apparently, with regard to overseas recruitment,
three-year contracts would be the best solution. Another issue was the new police
building and drug court on Court Street. An Island of 65,000 inhabitants with a
'drug Court'. That is some serious drug problem!
Bermudian's do not need to be other than introverted.
That is not to say all are. The majority of the inhabitants are content with
their life-style and so they should be, they live on a beautiful island and enjoy a
peaceful existence. I would not put anyone off the island for a holiday or to work.
But there is a serious drug problem, worse than I have
ever encountered in the UK. Bermuda's laws are sufficient (Asset Forfeiture needs to
be revisited) and the Courts have the power to hand out deterrent sentences. Still
the offences are committed by many. Why? Because law enforcement is
disjointed, ineffectual, self-serving and inexperienced. There is little fear
associated with capture because the rewards are high and the probability of detection low.
If caught there is a general belief a prosecution will not
follow or will be unsuccessful. With the current in-fighting in the force a further
distraction, the effectiveness of the police service is diluted still further. Only
last year an officer admitted, in a drug trial, to be asked to change her statement by
fellow officers!
Did heads roll? No - in my mind the officers behind
that farce can never be trusted to give an accurate account of an incident. Their
credibility has gone, they are worthless in a confrontational, active, situation.
But hey, it's Bermuda. If that's the quality of police service you want, then expect
the resultant level of detection and conviction. Blank search warrants, a narcotics
office with sufficient 'spare evidence' to taint and sample passing through it and the
sheer audacity to expect a fellow officer to change their evidence, are all indicative of
a department out of control, a law unto themselves. How is anyone expected to take
the service seriously?
As for experienced officers ...
If I want a new bathroom suite fitted, I hire a plumber.
If my car breaks down I call a mechanic. In short, I employ someone with the
appropriate skills and the correct tools to efficiently eradicate the problem.
Bermuda should be purchasing the skills and providing the tools. The island is
attractive to many potential overseas recruits and this has 'purchasing power'.
Bermuda has something to offer; an good environment, a career (possibly) and attractive
salary. Why hire 10 officers for 5 years when you could have 20 officer for 2.5
years?
You could swamp the island with trained officers in the
short term. Admittedly, it takes time to become acquitted with the island and there
is a cost in bringing an officer back from overseas if they are subsequently required to
give evidence. But in terms of the overall cost of being tarnished with a drug
capital of the world label, this expense is minimal.
It all appears to be about cost. Not cost to the
inhabitants, but cost to the Government.
If your house is burgled by a junkie, claim on your
Insurance. There is no cost to the Government. If you are assaulted by a drug
user during a robbery, claim on your insurance and see your doctor. Little cost to
the Government. If a bank is robbed, odds on the haul will be minimal and swallowed
by the bank as accountable 'wastage'. No, or little cost to the Government.
The cost comes in investigating, supplying the staff,
facilities and equipment. Let's face it, narcotics is a 'victimless crime', it is
not a quantifiable statistic.
'Victimless' is harsh when we know there are users who
suffer and frequently die. But they chose (not in every case) to participate and
knew (not in every case) the risks. My sympathy is extended to the families of drug
users. But the crime is 'victimless' in that it is principally about the buying a
selling of a commodity. Simple supply and demand considerations demonstrate that the
commodity is desired by many. The commodity is the subject of prohibition
which creates the 'crime'.
But unless the 'crime' is detected, in the main it stays
underground. It principally surfaces when there is the need to commit crime for
funding the habit or a death occurs. Otherwise, it not seen and effectively troubles
no one. There are health, work and safety issues associated with its use but l have
yet to see these make the headlines.
Unless your narcotics and Customs officers are making
arrests and seizures, there is no means by which to quantify the problem. That the
only means by which to quantify the problem is the seizure statistics it follows that you
should reduce the number of narcotics officers - less officers = less arrests = reduced
seizures = less of a quantifiable 'problem'.
I do not advocate the above, it simply demonstrates the
farcical in which Bermuda finds itself. You already have the highest density of
police officers per head of population anywhere in the world, you want more. It
appears your Government do not want to pay the price and secure for you a competent
service.
I would suggest the way to gauge the drug problem on the
Island is by the price of the commodity. Narcotics prices have not increased in the
last 10, possibly 20 years. Again, simple 'supply and demand' logic dictates the
island's police and Customs services have had no effect on the problem. If you
consider supply and demand in terms of the product we are dealing with (narcotics) I would
suggest distributors are unlikely to lower their price even if supply increases.
This is partly due to the fact that the product is unusual in that it is illegal, this
enhances its value and I suspect is used, in times of high supply, to keep prices
constant.
At best the island is maintaining the status quo. In
reality I suspect the island is losing and the supply is increasing.
It must be remembered; drug dealers have few rules, no
laws. You do not dictate a drug dealers habits or resources. What the drug
suppler wants he gets, whether by further crime or simply spending his ill-gotten gains.
Whether it is the means by which to import or distribute, the dealer can buy the
latest. Law enforcement agencies do not have this luxury - requests for equipment
are met by budgetary restrictions. Access to information or other evidence may
require beaurocratic procedures to be adopted. Even when it comes to legal
representation. The drug dealer can retain the best. Whilst there are some
very good, conscientious, public minded lawyers who work for Governments, the question
often posed of them is "why, if you are any good, work for a Government salary when
you could be making good money in private practice". For some the answer is
simple, they wish to provide a public service. The suggestion however is that they
lack ability, the Government gets the left overs. I appreciate this is a little
simplistic.
Most Bermudan officers simply do not have the opportunity
to gain enough experience. Why not reverse the roles. Send Bermudian officers,
young men and women, to work in some of the busier areas of the UK for 6 months, a year?
The experience they will gain would exceed their wildest dreams. Why not
approach the Metropolitan police service? There is said to be a problem with 'institutionalized
racism', so send the UK some Bermudan officers to mix with the established service.
The above are just ideas 'off the top of my head'.
Bermuda needs to think laterally if it to tackle the problem. You will achieve
nothing if you simply throw more local officers at a task they are ill-equipped to deal
with. Similarly, you do not need to import a load of English beach-bums who have no
interest in committing themselves to tackling the communities problems.
But first, get your house in order.
The discipline code continues to divide the lower ranks
from the Officer cadre. FSI are a tool of oppression and create a 'them and us'
environment. The manner in which discipline is applied reflects nothing short of
bullying tactics and for many it is simpler and safer to be silent than criticise.
Such fear promotes greater abuses; the perpetrators, having succeeded once, gain
confidence and experience. Abuses are the norm.
Bermuda has very little in its police service to be proud
of. Certainly holding the record for the highest number of police officers per head
of population, on a small, tranquil island, is hardly a glowing accolade. If you do
not have a crime problem then there is clearly a problem with return fromt he staff.
How can other countries survive greater crime problems with less officers?
Greater productivity?
The recent promotions reflect an inherent problem; the
lack of experienced officers from which to pick 'leaders' ....
PROMOTIONS - ANOTHER EXAMPLE OF DISCRIMINATION?
Apparently, the appointment of a Bermudian Police
Commissioner has moved closer to reality. Three local officers were promoted to the
top of the service. Chief Inspectors Gertrude Barker, Jonathan Smith and George
Jackson were promoted to the rank of Superintendent.
Commissioner Jean-Jacques Lemay, remains the only
ex-patriate officer in the top flight. Deputy Commissioner Harold Moniz is Bermudian while
third in command, Assistant Commissioner Alan Bissell, has Bermudian status.
With this concentration of Bermudian Officers holding the
most powerful and influential positions in the service, one could be forgiven for thinking
there is no place for believing there is a future for the ex-pat. But it appears
equality does not come into it. You must be a Bermudian or have status to succeed.
It is evident this is the way of the police service, the
island demands it. Employment for the ex-pat is short term and hazardous.
I have met each of the officer above with the exception of
the COP, Mr. Lemay who, I have already detailed on this site, I consider to be a liar.
Mr. Lemay has made a false statement and I trust anyone who is confronted by him
will bear this in mind. To quote Julian Hall, when defending one of those associated
with the Miranda investigation (1991):
"My client is a liar, but he is telling the truth
now"
Possibly the same could be said for the COP, Mr. Lemay.
But how do you know when he is lying? If I were cynical I would say that this
occurs when his lips move. Mr. Lemay, from my experience, is someone who cannot be
trusted.
Of the recent promotions, I was amazed to see George
Jackson yet again moving upward. George was probably the most ineffectual officer I
met in the Narcotics office and was totally out of his depth. Furthermore, he lacks
the strength to support his fellow officer. When dealing with George, obtain
everything in writing - he will double back on what has been said or forget his remarks,
whatever offers the least line of resistance.
One day he informed me not to report the ongoing
investigation to the head of Narcotics, Dennis Ramsey. Within 7 days I was before
the COP being told my move back to uniform was for insubordination (not keeping the head
of Narco advised of the ongoing investigation). George Jackson was present when I
was informed of this by the COP, he said nothing.
George was also one of the Officers who was aware the
Narco office used blank, signed (by a J.P.) search warrants. I suspect he has denied
this emphatically. More will be revealed about this Officer as the Miranda pages
progress to include comments made by overseas investigators. In brief, the standing
joke was George could not find his arse-hole with a magnifying glass and a mirror.
If he wanted to win an argument, he simply shouted louder than anyone else. If you
wanted to distract him, simply mention another subject when he was talking to someone and
he'd go off at a tangent.
Mention has been made of political promotions in the
press. I can only assume that is precisely what has happened with George.
'George for Commissioner of Police', let us herald the dawning of another crime wave and
set the island back still further.
Do you really have such a lack of faith in your officers
or a belief that they are incompetent that you are forced to resort to such extreme
measures. God help you.